SonglyGift and JustOurSong start the same way: a few questions, then a free preview of your own song. The difference is in how much you can shape the sound, how the song is finished, and how long you have if something isn't right.
This review is published by JustOurSong. Details about SonglyGift were checked on its website, song quiz, FAQ and terms of service in October 2026, along with SonglyGift reviews on Trustpilot.
The Short Version
SonglyGift can suit you if you want a quick song and you're sure you'll love it within a day. JustOurSong is the choice when it has to be right on the day: more genres and occasions, a studio-grade finish, and 30 days to be sure.
Key takeaways
- Before you pay: both play you a free preview. With JustOurSong you also shape more of the song first: a wider range of genres, the vocalist, the vibe, and occasions like a proposal or an apology.
- How it's made: JustOurSong writes each song from scratch for one story, puts it through studio-grade quality control and masters it until it's radio-ready. Lyrics are never reused.
- After delivery: JustOurSong gives you a free redo for any change, big or small, to the words or the music, plus 30 days to ask for your money back. JustOurSong's YouTube video add-on makes the reveal easy too: one tap, and the song plays for everyone on the TV. SonglyGift's FAQ gives you 24 hours after delivery to ask for a new version.
Platform Overview
SonglyGift
SonglyGift writes a song from a short quiz and plays you a free preview a few minutes later. After you buy, the full song is emailed to you.
JustOurSong
JustOurSong starts with a short guide that feels like telling a friend about someone: who the song is for, the occasion, the genre, the vocalist, the vibe, then the memories worth singing about. From that, JustOurSong writes a song that sounds like it belongs on the radio, written from scratch with lyrics that are never reused, in many genres, like country, Latin pop, R&B, soul, Christian and others. JustOurSong plays you a free preview before you pay, and the finished song comes by email as a link to a private song page, where you can play it, share it and download the high-quality MP3 and the lyrics.
At a Glance
| JustOurSong | SonglyGift | |
|---|---|---|
| Hear it before you pay | ✓Free preview | ✓Free preview |
| Song quality | ✓Written from scratch, studio-grade quality control, radio-ready master | Promises a "studio-quality" song |
| Genres | ✓Many more genres, like country, classic rock, Christian, pop, R&B, Latin pop, cinematic ballads, soul, bachata, acoustic pop, alt rock, jazz, rap/hip-hop, reggae and others | Prayer song, pop, country, rock, R&B, folk, jazz, hip hop or classical |
| Occasions | ✓Any occasion, including a proposal and an apology, or one you describe yourself | Birthday, wedding, anniversary, graduation, thank you, just because, memorial or holiday |
| Song language | ✓English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Portuguese and many more | English |
| Changes after delivery | ✓A free redo: minor or major changes to the lyrics or the music | One new version if you ask within 24 hours |
| Money back | ✓30-day money-back guarantee | Only if you ask within 24 hours and the new version still isn't right |
| Gift presentation | ✓Optional YouTube video the whole family can play in one tap, on a phone or the living-room TV | A gifting page, but no YouTube video |
| Trustpilot rating | 5 stars | 4.7 |
What You Can Shape Before You Pay
With JustOurSong you choose:
- The genre: many to choose from, like country, classic rock, alt rock, soul, jazz, indie pop, Christian, a cinematic ballad, bachata, mariachi and others
- The vocalist and the vibe: upbeat and happy, soulful and deep, romantic, funny, or epic and powerful
- The occasion: a birthday, anniversary, proposal, wedding, graduation, apology, Christmas, New Year, a song in memory of someone, just because, or any moment you describe in your own words
- The details: nicknames, inside jokes, the first flat, the song from the kitchen
- The language: English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Portuguese and many more
SonglyGift's quiz offers nine styles (prayer song, pop, country, rock, R&B, folk, jazz, hip hop and classical) and eight occasions. There's no proposal or apology, and songs are written in English only.
If the song is for a proposal, a first dance or a family that speaks Spanish, JustOurSong is the stronger pick.
How It Sounds When You Press Play
Every JustOurSong song gets:
- A natural songwriting structure: verses, and a chorus they'll hum for days
- Studio-grade quality control before it reaches you
- A radio-ready master that sounds full on a phone, in the car or over the speakers at the party
SonglyGift says your preview is ready in about two to three minutes. JustOurSong takes the time to check every song with studio-grade quality control before it reaches you.
If it's playing out loud at the celebration, JustOurSong is the choice you won't second-guess.
What Happens After Delivery
JustOurSong
- A free redo, covering minor or major changes to the lyrics or the music
- 30 days to change your mind, with a full refund
SonglyGift
- 24 hours after delivery to ask for a new version
- A full refund only if that new version still isn't right
- Its terms say it "cannot guarantee specific outcomes or styles"
That 24 hours matters when you buy ahead. A song ordered two weeks before an anniversary is past SonglyGift's window long before anyone hears it.
If you're ordering early for a big day, JustOurSong is the one to choose.
Does SonglyGift Offer Refunds?
Yes, within a short window. Its FAQ says that if you tell it within 24 hours of receiving your song, it will make a new version for free, and if that's still not right, you get a full refund. Its terms say the same, and neither describes a refund after those 24 hours.
JustOurSong's guarantee runs for 30 days. If it's not what you hoped for, email JustOurSong for a full refund.
What Customers Say
JustOurSong is rated 5 stars on Trustpilot, and those stars cover what a 24-hour window can't: how people feel about the song days and weeks later. They still play it. They still cry at it. Some come back to order another.
I was blown away by the quality of our song.
This was just THE best present I could have given my husband for our anniversary!
I couldn't listen to either one and make it to the end without ugly crying.
Barbara asked JustOurSong for a redo, and "it was to perfection!" Maggie calls the song the "best gift you could ever give!" Read more JustOurSong reviews.
SonglyGift is rated 4.7 on Trustpilot. Its profile there says it typically takes over a month to reply to negative reviews. Its low-star reviews mostly describe change and refund requests that went unanswered, repeat charges buyers didn't expect, and names left out of the song. When you want more than a day to be sure, JustOurSong's 5 stars and 30-day guarantee have you covered.
Who Should Choose Which?
Our verdict
If you want time to be sure after the song arrives, JustOurSong is the stronger pick.
Choose JustOurSong if: you want a song they'll play on repeat: more genres and occasions, a song in their language, a free redo for any change to the lyrics or the music, and 30 days to change your mind.
Choose SonglyGift if: you want a quick song for one of its occasions and you'll know within a day whether it's right.
Give a song you can be sure of
Tell us your story, hear your free preview, and keep 30 days to change your mind.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to ask SonglyGift for changes?
24 hours after you receive the song, according to its FAQ. JustOurSong's free redo covers minor or major changes, and you have 30 days to get your money back.
Which has the more generous refund policy?
JustOurSong. Its money-back guarantee lasts 30 days. SonglyGift's FAQ only describes refunds within 24 hours of receiving the song.
Which is better for a gift bought weeks ahead?
JustOurSong, because its 30-day money-back guarantee still covers you when the big day comes. SonglyGift's FAQ window closes 24 hours after delivery.
Which has more music styles to choose from?
JustOurSong. SonglyGift's quiz offers prayer song, pop, country, rock, R&B, folk, jazz, hip hop and classical. JustOurSong adds classic and alt rock, soul, indie pop, Christian, cinematic ballads, reggaeton, bachata, mariachi and more.
Can SonglyGift change the style of my song?
Its terms say it "cannot guarantee specific outcomes or styles", and you have 24 hours to ask for a new version. JustOurSong's free redo covers minor or major changes to the lyrics or the music.
Which is better for a proposal song?
JustOurSong, because you can choose a proposal as the occasion and shape the genre, the vocalist and the vibe. SonglyGift's quiz has no proposal occasion.
Can SonglyGift write a song in Spanish?
Its songs are written in English, and its quiz offers no other language. JustOurSong writes songs in English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Portuguese and many more.
What do SonglyGift reviews say?
SonglyGift is rated 4.7 on Trustpilot, and its profile says it typically takes over a month to reply to negative reviews. Its low-star reviews mostly mention unanswered change and refund requests, repeat charges and names left out of the song. JustOurSong is rated 5 stars on Trustpilot.
Sources: SonglyGift's homepage, song quiz, FAQ and terms of service; the Trustpilot pages for SonglyGift and JustOurSong. Checked October 2026.